Презентация на тему Подготовка научной статьи для публикации в международном журнале

анализируется содержательная часть статьи
Оценивается качество написания
Дается рекомендация: печатать или

отклонить
Если необходимо, приводятся конкретные замечания и рекомендации

Very Good

Good
Fair
Poor

paper present new ideas or results that have not

been previously published?
Yes Minor No
2. Are the results/ideas presented in this paper important for this Journal?
Definitely Perhaps No
3. Is the paper technically correct?
Yes No Not sure
4. Are the contents supported/verified by independent evidence (measurements, prior results, etc.)?
Yes No
5. Is previous related work adequately referenced?
Yes No
(If not, indicate omissions.)

the paper present a critical assessment of the current

state-of-the-art?
Yes Not adequately No
2. Have all the previous important publications in this area been referred to and commented on?
(if not, list the important omissions.)
Yes Mostly No
3 .To what extent is this review useful to the «ХХХ» community?
Much Average Little

the paper.
10 - - - 9 - -

- 8 - - - 7 - - - 6- - - 5- - - 4- - - 2- - - 1
Clear, concise, effective (10-6)
Obscure, verbose, disorganized (5-1)
3. Is the paper concise for publication?
Yes No
4. Is the grammar/spelling adequate for publication? (Please note errors on manuscript.)
Yes No
5. Is the abstract an appropriate and adequate digest of the work?
Yes No

English
Yes No

Good Title
Yes No

Clear Figures
Yes No

minor changes)

as a Paper
2. Accept subject to suitable revision as a Short Paper
3. Accept with major revision and resubmit
4. Reject, do not reconsider
5. More suitable for publication in another journal such as _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _